What games are like American Arcadia?

indielist matches 12 indie games to American Arcadia by shared genre and Steam tags, led by What Remains of Edith Finch (46,288 reviews). The list is ranked by review count.

How are "games like American Arcadia" chosen?

By overlap of Steam tags and primary genre with American Arcadia, weighted by review count as a popularity signal. It is computed from tracked data, not hand-picked, and updates as the catalog grows.

Games like American Arcadia

Looking for games like American Arcadia? indielist surfaces 12 similar indie games by shared genre and Steam tags, ranked by review count. American Arcadia is a adventure game from 2023; the closest matches share its tags and audience. The top match by reviews is What Remains of Edith Finch with 46,288 Steam reviews. Each game links to a white-box sales estimate you can audit. Matches are computed from tracked Steam data, not editorial opinion.

W

What Remains of Edith Finch

2017 · Adventure

46,288 reviews · 96% positive

Story RichAtmosphericFirst-Person

Same: shares Story Rich and Atmospheric. Different: leans more into walking simulator.
C

Cloudpunk

2020 · Adventure

13,617 reviews · 88% positive

CyberpunkAtmosphericSci-fi

Same: shares Cyberpunk and Atmospheric. Different: leans more into open world.
A

Axiom Verge

2015 · Action

6,559 reviews · 90% positive

Indie2DSci-fi

Same: shares Indie and 2D. Different: leans more into metroidvania.
S

Stray

2022 · Adventure

155,602 reviews · 97% positive

AdventureAtmosphericCyberpunk

Same: shares Adventure and Atmospheric. Different: leans more into cats.
M

MiSide

2024 · Adventure

120,369 reviews · 98% positive

Story RichHorrorFirst-Person

Same: shares Story Rich and Horror. Different: leans more into psychological horror.
S

Subnautica: Below Zero

2021 · Adventure

98,838 reviews · 90% positive

SingleplayerHorrorExploration

Same: shares Singleplayer and Horror. Different: leans more into open world survival craft.
F

Firewatch

2016 · Adventure

93,069 reviews · 91% positive

AdventureAtmosphericStory Rich

Same: shares Adventure and Atmospheric. Different: leans more into walking simulator.
M

Mouthwashing

2024 · Adventure

37,868 reviews · 95% positive

Story RichHorrorAtmospheric

Same: shares Story Rich and Horror. Different: leans more into psychological horror.
S

Sally Face - Episode One

2016 · Adventure

25,241 reviews · 97% positive

Story RichIndieHorror

Same: shares Story Rich and Indie. Different: leans more into psychological horror.
G

Gone Home

2013 · Adventure

13,575 reviews · 77% positive

IndieExplorationAtmospheric

Same: shares Indie and Exploration. Different: leans more into walking simulator.
T

The Mortuary Assistant

2022 · Adventure

7,171 reviews · 92% positive

HorrorAtmosphericSimulation

Same: shares Horror and Atmospheric. Different: leans more into supernatural.
T

Tangle Tower

2019 · Adventure

6,421 reviews · 95% positive

Point & ClickExplorationVisual Novel

Same: shares Point & Click and Exploration. Different: leans more into detective.

Frequently asked questions

What games are like American Arcadia?: indielist matches 12 indie games to American Arcadia by shared genre and Steam tags, led by What Remains of Edith Finch (46,288 reviews). The list is ranked by review count.
How are "games like American Arcadia" chosen?: By overlap of Steam tags and primary genre with American Arcadia, weighted by review count as a popularity signal. It is computed from tracked data, not hand-picked, and updates as the catalog grows.