Underrated Multiple Endings indie games you missed
These are underrated multiple endings indie games: titles with strong reviews but not yet the audience they deserve. indielist surfaces 15 multiple endings games that each hold at least 80% positive Steam reviews while staying under 5,000 total ratings : the sweet spot where a game has proven itself with real players but hasn't broken out yet. Together they hold 30,801 reviews at an average of 92% positive. They are ranked by review count, so the most-validated picks lead, and each links to a white-box sales estimate you can open and check rather than a black-box number. The most reviewed here is I Was a Teenage Exocolonist with 4,652 reviews. Review counts and ratings are from Steam; sales figures are modeled estimates, not official sales data.
Hidden gems
15
Avg positive %
92%
Total reviews
30,801
-
I Was a Teenage Exocolonist
2022 · Indie
4,652 reviews · 96% positive
-
That's not my Neighbor
2025 · Adventure
4,412 reviews · 89% positive
-
Monster Prom 3: Monster Roadtrip
2022 · Casual
3,286 reviews · 97% positive
-
Love Curse: Find Your Soulmate
2025 · RPG
3,123 reviews · 95% positive
-
Myst
2021 · Adventure
2,139 reviews · 89% positive
-
Monster Prom 4: Monster Con
2025 · Casual
2,066 reviews · 99% positive
-
Doors: Paradox
2022 · Adventure
2,013 reviews · 91% positive
-
Rusted Moss
2023 · Action
1,610 reviews · 89% positive
-
Duck Season
2017 · Action
1,589 reviews · 85% positive
-
JudgeSim
2024 · Casual
1,361 reviews · 84% positive
-
Grunn
2024 · Adventure
1,340 reviews · 96% positive
-
Escape From Mystwood Mansion
2023 · Action
1,278 reviews · 93% positive
-
The Use of Life
2025 · Adventure
767 reviews · 91% positive
-
A Highland Song
2023 · Adventure
649 reviews · 88% positive
-
Studio System : Guardian Angel
2025 · Action
516 reviews · 94% positive
Frequently asked questions
- What are some underrated multiple endings indie games?
- indielist lists 15 underrated multiple endings indie games, each with 80%+ Steam reviews but under 5,000 ratings, led by I Was a Teenage Exocolonist (4,652 reviews).
- How are these "hidden gem" multiple endings games chosen?
- By a data filter, not opinion: a game qualifies if it holds at least 80% positive Steam reviews and has between 50 and 5,000 total ratings, enough to be validated by players but not yet mainstream. The list updates as the catalog grows.