What are some underrated supernatural indie games?

indielist lists 13 underrated supernatural indie games, each with 80%+ Steam reviews but under 5,000 ratings, led by Scarlet Hollow (4,927 reviews).

How are these "hidden gem" supernatural games chosen?

By a data filter, not opinion: a game qualifies if it holds at least 80% positive Steam reviews and has between 50 and 5,000 total ratings, enough to be validated by players but not yet mainstream. The list updates as the catalog grows.

Underrated Supernatural indie games you missed

These are underrated supernatural indie games: titles with strong reviews but not yet the audience they deserve. indielist surfaces 13 supernatural games that each hold at least 80% positive Steam reviews while staying under 5,000 total ratings : the sweet spot where a game has proven itself with real players but hasn't broken out yet. Together they hold 25,649 reviews at an average of 92% positive. They are ranked by review count, so the most-validated picks lead, and each links to a white-box sales estimate you can open and check rather than a black-box number. The most reviewed here is Scarlet Hollow with 4,927 reviews. Review counts and ratings are from Steam; sales figures are estimates, not official sales data.

Hidden gems

Avg positive %

92%

Total reviews

25,649

Frequently asked questions

What are some underrated supernatural indie games?: indielist lists 13 underrated supernatural indie games, each with 80%+ Steam reviews but under 5,000 ratings, led by Scarlet Hollow (4,927 reviews).
How are these "hidden gem" supernatural games chosen?: By a data filter, not opinion: a game qualifies if it holds at least 80% positive Steam reviews and has between 50 and 5,000 total ratings, enough to be validated by players but not yet mainstream. The list updates as the catalog grows.