What games are like That's not my Neighbor?

indielist matches 12 indie games to That's not my Neighbor by shared genre and Steam tags, led by Little Misfortune (13,732 reviews). The list is ranked by review count.

How are "games like That's not my Neighbor" chosen?

By overlap of Steam tags and primary genre with That's not my Neighbor, weighted by review count as a popularity signal. It is computed from tracked data, not hand-picked, and updates as the catalog grows.

Games like That's not my Neighbor

Looking for games like That's not my Neighbor? indielist surfaces 12 similar indie games by shared genre and Steam tags, ranked by review count. That's not my Neighbor is a adventure game from 2025; the closest matches share its tags and audience. The top match by reviews is Little Misfortune with 13,732 Steam reviews. Each game links to a white-box sales estimate you can audit. Matches are computed from tracked Steam data, not editorial opinion.

Little Misfortune

2019 · Adventure

13,732 reviews · 92% positive

Psychological HorrorPoint & ClickIndie

Same: shares Psychological Horror and Point & Click. Different: leans more into story rich.
Grunn

2024 · Adventure

1,340 reviews · 96% positive

HorrorMultiple EndingsChoices Matter

Same: shares Horror and Multiple Endings. Different: leans more into farming sim.
Papers, Please

2013 · Adventure

72,058 reviews · 97% positive

IndieSimulationPoint & Click

Same: shares Indie and Simulation. Different: leans more into political.
OneShot

2016 · Adventure

57,172 reviews · 98% positive

IndiePuzzleSingleplayer

Same: shares Indie and Puzzle. Different: leans more into story rich.
Sally Face - Episode One

2016 · Adventure

24,760 reviews · 97% positive

Psychological HorrorIndieHorror

Same: shares Psychological Horror and Indie. Different: leans more into story rich.
Mad Father

2016 · Adventure

6,538 reviews · 97% positive

HorrorPsychological Horror2D

Same: shares Horror and Psychological Horror. Different: leans more into rpgmaker.
Birth

2023 · Adventure

4,016 reviews · 96% positive

Point & ClickPuzzleAdventure

Same: shares Point & Click and Puzzle. Different: leans more into surreal.
Myst

2021 · Adventure

2,139 reviews · 89% positive

AdventurePuzzleFirst-Person

Same: shares Adventure and Puzzle. Different: leans more into exploration.
Doors: Paradox

2022 · Adventure

2,013 reviews · 91% positive

PuzzlePoint & ClickMultiple Endings

Same: shares Puzzle and Point & Click. Different: leans more into mystery.
SILENT BREATH

2024 · Adventure

1,201 reviews · 69% positive

HorrorPsychological HorrorThriller

Same: shares Horror and Psychological Horror. Different: leans more into 1990's.
JudgeSim

2024 · Casual

1,361 reviews · 84% positive

SimulationIndie2D

Same: shares Simulation and Indie. Different: leans more into text-based.
The Henry Stickmin Collection

2020 · Adventure

53,634 reviews · 99% positive

Multiple EndingsSingleplayerChoices Matter

Same: shares Multiple Endings and Singleplayer. Different: leans more into funny.

Frequently asked questions

What games are like That's not my Neighbor?: indielist matches 12 indie games to That's not my Neighbor by shared genre and Steam tags, led by Little Misfortune (13,732 reviews). The list is ranked by review count.
How are "games like That's not my Neighbor" chosen?: By overlap of Steam tags and primary genre with That's not my Neighbor, weighted by review count as a popularity signal. It is computed from tracked data, not hand-picked, and updates as the catalog grows.