What games are like The Caribbean Sail?

indielist matches 12 indie games to The Caribbean Sail by shared genre and Steam tags, led by Rust (1,383,303 reviews). The list is ranked by review count.

How are "games like The Caribbean Sail" chosen?

By overlap of Steam tags and primary genre with The Caribbean Sail, weighted by review count as a popularity signal. It is computed from tracked data, not hand-picked, and updates as the catalog grows.

Games like The Caribbean Sail

Looking for games like The Caribbean Sail? indielist surfaces 12 similar indie games by shared genre and Steam tags, ranked by review count. The Caribbean Sail is a action game from 2017; the closest matches share its tags and audience. The top match by reviews is Rust with 1,383,303 Steam reviews. Each game links to a white-box sales estimate you can audit. Matches are computed from tracked Steam data, not editorial opinion.

R

Rust

2018 · Action

1,383,303 reviews · 87% positive

Same: same action focus. Different: leans more into survival.
T

Terraria

2011 · Action

1,227,439 reviews · 97% positive

Same: same action focus. Different: leans more into open world survival craft.
P

Phasmophobia

2020 · Action

680,386 reviews · 94% positive

Same: same action focus. Different: leans more into horror.
A

ARK: Survival Evolved

2017 · Action

583,081 reviews · 83% positive

Same: same action focus. Different: leans more into open world survival craft.
G

Geometry Dash

2014 · Action

578,930 reviews · 93% positive

Same: same action focus. Different: leans more into difficult.
T

The Forest

2018 · Action

577,971 reviews · 96% positive

Same: same action focus. Different: leans more into open world survival craft.
H

Hollow Knight

2017 · Action

495,505 reviews · 97% positive

Same: same action focus. Different: leans more into metroidvania.
V

Valheim

2021 · Action

455,972 reviews · 94% positive

Same: same action focus. Different: leans more into open world survival craft.
L

Lethal Company

2023 · Action

410,693 reviews · 97% positive

Same: same action focus. Different: leans more into online co-op.
B

Brawlhalla

2017 · Action

409,586 reviews · 80% positive

Same: same action focus. Different: leans more into free to play.
T

The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth

2014 · Action

393,010 reviews · 97% positive

Same: same action focus. Different: leans more into action roguelike.
H

Hollow Knight: Silksong

2025 · Action

380,613 reviews · 89% positive

Same: same action focus. Different: a 2025 take.

Frequently asked questions

What games are like The Caribbean Sail?: indielist matches 12 indie games to The Caribbean Sail by shared genre and Steam tags, led by Rust (1,383,303 reviews). The list is ranked by review count.
How are "games like The Caribbean Sail" chosen?: By overlap of Steam tags and primary genre with The Caribbean Sail, weighted by review count as a popularity signal. It is computed from tracked data, not hand-picked, and updates as the catalog grows.