Mystery indie games
indielist tracks 136 indie mystery games with the Steam user tag "Mystery", together holding 2,458,884 reviews at an average of 91% positive. The most reviewed is Phasmophobia with 680,735 reviews.
Tagged titles
136
Total reviews on Steam
2,458,884
Avg positive %
91%
Live data report
Open the live data report for the best mystery indie games, ranked from the same catalog with methodology, review counts, and white-box sales estimate links.
Open Mystery data reportRelated tags
Adventure (44) Story Rich (39) Horror (30) First-Person (28) Puzzle (28) Exploration (25) Psychological Horror (23) Dark (18) Casual (17) Point & Click (15)
- P
Phasmophobia
2020 · Action
680,735 reviews · 94% positive
HorrorOnline Co-OpMultiplayerPsychological HorrorCo-op
- S
- D
DELTARUNE
2025 · Indie
114,321 reviews · 98% positive
Story RichGreat SoundtrackPixel GraphicsFunnyRPG
- F
Firewatch
2016 · Adventure
93,148 reviews · 91% positive
AdventureAtmosphericStory RichWalking SimulatorMystery
- O
- C
Core Keeper
2024 · Action
65,685 reviews · 93% positive
Pixel GraphicsOpen World Survival CraftOnline Co-OpSandboxSurvival
- G
- S
SOMA
2015 · Action
52,105 reviews · 96% positive
HorrorPsychological HorrorAtmosphericDarkStory Rich
- D
- W
- P
Poppy Playtime
2021 · Action
38,370 reviews · 88% positive
HorrorFree to PlaySingleplayerPuzzleFirst-Person
- T
The Stanley Parable: Ultra Deluxe
2022 · Adventure
35,587 reviews · 94% positive
Multiple EndingsComedyChoices MatterWalking SimulatorNarration
- R
Return of the Obra Dinn
2018 · Adventure
34,782 reviews · 97% positive
DetectiveMysteryPuzzleStory RichAtmospheric
- J
Journey
2020 · Adventure
34,471 reviews · 94% positive
BeautifulAtmosphericAdventureIndieExploration
- M
Mouthwashing
2024 · Adventure
33,709 reviews · 95% positive
Psychological HorrorStory RichHorrorAtmosphericRetro
- T
The Talos Principle
2014 · Action
32,940 reviews · 95% positive
PuzzlePhilosophicalFirst-PersonSci-fiAtmospheric
- U
- T
The Room
2014 · Adventure
30,194 reviews · 98% positive
PuzzleMysteryPoint & ClickAtmosphericSingleplayer
- C
- B
Bendy and the Ink Machine
2017 · Action
25,658 reviews · 89% positive
HorrorFirst-PersonSingleplayerPuzzleCartoony
- S
- F
Five Nights at Freddy's 2
2014 · Indie
23,645 reviews · 94% positive
HorrorSingleplayerSurvival HorrorRobotsPsychological Horror
- A
ANIMAL WELL
2024 · Action
22,562 reviews · 96% positive
MetroidvaniaExplorationPuzzlePixel GraphicsPuzzle-Platformer
- T
The Room Two
2016 · Adventure
21,602 reviews · 98% positive
PuzzleMysteryPoint & ClickAtmosphericHidden Object
- B
- G
- D
Demonologist
2023 · Action
18,671 reviews · 85% positive
HorrorMultiplayerOnline Co-OpPsychological HorrorCo-op
- U
Until Then
2024 · Adventure
18,266 reviews · 97% positive
Visual NovelPixel GraphicsEmotionalInteractive FictionStory Rich
- T
The Witness
2016 · Adventure
16,982 reviews · 84% positive
PuzzleExplorationFirst-PersonOpen WorldSingleplayer
- B
Blue Prince
2025 · Adventure
16,888 reviews · 86% positive
PuzzleExplorationMysteryInvestigationSingleplayer
- K
- E
Escape Simulator
2021 · Adventure
16,398 reviews · 94% positive
PuzzleCo-opMultiplayerEscape RoomFirst-Person
- M
- S
- T
The Past Within
2022 · Adventure
14,508 reviews · 95% positive
Co-opPuzzleOnline Co-OpMultiplayerEscape Room
- W
We Were Here Together
2019 · Adventure
14,360 reviews · 82% positive
PuzzleOnline Co-OpCo-op CampaignStory RichEscape Room
- G
Gone Home
2013 · Adventure
13,575 reviews · 77% positive
Walking SimulatorShortIndieExplorationAtmospheric
- T
- T
- F
- F
Five Nights at Freddy's: Sister Location
2016 · Action
11,387 reviews · 90% positive
HorrorSurvival HorrorSingleplayerRobotsFirst-Person
- T
Tactical Breach Wizards
2024 · Adventure
11,327 reviews · 98% positive
Turn-Based TacticsPuzzleTurn-Based StrategyStory RichTurn-Based
- F
Five Nights at Freddy's 3
2015 · Action
10,290 reviews · 90% positive
HorrorSingleplayerSurvival HorrorRobotsFirst-Person
- K
Kindergarten
2017 · Adventure
10,118 reviews · 97% positive
FunnyGorePixel GraphicsSingleplayerViolent
- I
Iron Lung
2022 · Adventure
10,023 reviews · 92% positive
HorrorAtmosphericPsychological HorrorSubmarineUnderwater
- T
- R
- D
- T
The Roottrees are Dead
2025 · Adventure
9,035 reviews · 97% positive
MysteryPuzzleDetectivePoint & ClickAtmospheric
- W
WORLD OF HORROR
2023 · Indie
8,946 reviews · 90% positive
HorrorLovecraftianPixel GraphicsSurvival HorrorPsychological Horror
- W
We Were Here Too
2018 · Adventure
8,917 reviews · 78% positive
Online Co-OpEscape RoomPuzzleCo-opHorror
- O
- B
- L
Lost in Play
2022 · Adventure
7,799 reviews · 98% positive
PuzzlePoint & ClickIndieSingleplayerMystery
- D
- M
- G
Gloomwood
2022 · Action
7,370 reviews · 95% positive
Early AccessImmersive SimStealthSurvival HorrorFPS
- T
- T
The Mortuary Assistant
2022 · Adventure
7,180 reviews · 92% positive
HorrorSupernaturalDemonsMysteryAtmospheric
- T
THE LONGING
2020 · Adventure
6,922 reviews · 92% positive
Point & ClickWalking SimulatorChoose Your Own AdventureIdler2D
- U
- C
- T
- D
- T
The Cosmic Wheel Sisterhood
2023 · Adventure
5,441 reviews · 93% positive
Interactive FictionFemale ProtagonistMagicLGBTQ+Visual Novel
- C
Creaks
2020 · Adventure
5,165 reviews · 95% positive
PuzzleHand-drawnAtmosphericSurrealPuzzle-Platformer
- F
FAR: Changing Tides
2022 · Action
5,011 reviews · 92% positive
AtmosphericAction-AdventurePost-apocalypticPuzzle-Platformer2.5D
- S
Sol Cesto
2026 · Indie
4,850 reviews · 91% positive
Early AccessDungeon CrawlerTacticalRogue-likePuzzle
- G
- S
Scarlet Hollow
2021 · Adventure
4,576 reviews · 98% positive
Early AccessChoices MatterVisual NovelPsychological HorrorStory Rich
- C
- D
- R
- S
- M
- O
- W
- T
The Rise of the Golden Idol
2024 · Adventure
3,725 reviews · 93% positive
MysteryInvestigationDetectiveConspiracyAdventure
- F
- I
INFRA
2016 · Adventure
3,414 reviews · 88% positive
PuzzleExplorationAtmosphericWalking SimulatorAdventure
- F
- S
- P
Paradise Killer
2020 · Adventure
3,257 reviews · 93% positive
Story RichInvestigationFemale ProtagonistOpen WorldExploration
- A
- V
- K
Kentucky Route Zero: PC Edition
2013 · Adventure
3,220 reviews · 80% positive
AdventureAtmosphericIndiePoint & ClickSurreal
- B
- L
- B
- T
- T
- D
- N
NORCO
2022 · Adventure
2,725 reviews · 92% positive
Point & ClickAtmosphericStory RichPixel GraphicsMystery
- F
Fears to Fathom - Carson House
2023 · Adventure
2,684 reviews · 92% positive
Psychological HorrorAtmosphericHorrorEpisodicAdventure
- C
- D
- I
In Other Waters
2020 · Adventure
2,070 reviews · 87% positive
IndieAdventureExplorationAtmosphericStory Rich
- O
- T
- D
- M
- H
- T
- P
- D
- W
Welcome to Kowloon
2023 · Adventure
1,744 reviews · 81% positive
HorrorAtmosphericPsychological HorrorAdventureWalking Simulator
- T
- O
- C
Children of Silentown
2023 · Adventure
1,546 reviews · 87% positive
AtmosphericAdventurePoint & ClickPuzzleStory Rich
- D
- O
- A
- B
BLADECHIMERA
2025 · Action
1,320 reviews · 89% positive
MetroidvaniaSide ScrollerExploration2D PlatformerMartial Arts
- G
- T
- S
- L
- A
- T
- S
- S
- F
- E
- G
Ghost Janitors
2025 · Action
847 reviews · 86% positive
HorrorOnline Co-OpMultiplayerPsychological HorrorEarly Access
- L
Liminalcore
2024 · Adventure
737 reviews · 83% positive
Walking SimulatorPsychological HorrorAtmosphericAdventureExploration
- R
- D
- R
- T
- A
- T
The Anomaly Project
2024 · Action
514 reviews · 82% positive
AdventureOnline Co-OpCasualPsychological HorrorWalking Simulator
- B
- L
- A
- H
Higurashi When They Cry Hou+
2023 · Adventure
161 reviews · 86% positive
AdventureVisual NovelAnimePsychologicalSingleplayer
- M
Frequently asked questions
- What are the best mystery indie games?
- By Steam review count, indielist ranks 136 tracked mystery indie games led by Phasmophobia (680,735 reviews).
- How is the mystery list built?
- This page uses SteamSpy user tags from tracked games, then ranks matching public games by Steam review count. It is not hand-picked.