Choices Matter indie games
indielist tracks 130 indie choices matter games with the Steam user tag "Choices Matter", together holding 1,900,123 reviews at an average of 89% positive. The most reviewed is Undertale with 312,017 reviews.
Tagged titles
130
Total reviews on Steam
1,900,123
Avg positive %
89%
Related tags
Story Rich (36) Adventure (32) RPG (27) Simulation (24) Strategy (20) Multiple Endings (17) Casual (15) Pixel Graphics (14) Open World (13) Funny (12)
- U
Undertale
2015 · Indie
312,017 reviews · 97% positive
Great SoundtrackStory RichChoices MatterMultiple EndingsPixel Graphics
- B
Balatro
2024 · Casual
162,256 reviews · 98% positive
Card GameRoguelike DeckbuilderRogue-likeDeckbuildingSingleplayer
- D
- G
- T
- O
OneShot
2016 · Adventure
59,845 reviews · 98% positive
Story RichPixel GraphicsIndieGreat SoundtrackCute
- T
- T
- V
- P
Potion Craft: Alchemist Simulator
2022 · Indie
38,238 reviews · 93% positive
CraftingSingleplayerRelaxingSimulationMedieval
- T
The Stanley Parable: Ultra Deluxe
2022 · Adventure
34,504 reviews · 94% positive
Multiple EndingsComedyChoices MatterWalking SimulatorNarration
- W
Warhammer 40,000: Rogue Trader
2023 · Action
34,401 reviews · 88% positive
Character CustomizationCinematicStory RichTurn-Based StrategyDark Fantasy
- T
- L
- L
- S
Slay the Princess — The Pristine Cut
2023 · Adventure
32,619 reviews · 97% positive
Visual NovelChoices MatterPsychological HorrorHorrorChoose Your Own Adventure
- G
Gas Station Simulator
2021 · Casual
24,051 reviews · 88% positive
SimulationEconomyBuildingSingleplayerManagement
- F
- B
- M
Milk outside a bag of milk outside a bag of milk
2021 · Casual
20,935 reviews · 97% positive
Psychological HorrorVisual NovelPsychedelicPixel GraphicsStory Rich
- D
- H
- C
Choo-Choo Charles
2022 · Action
16,528 reviews · 91% positive
Survival HorrorHorrorOpen WorldFirst-PersonSingleplayer
- W
Wildermyth
2021 · Indie
16,382 reviews · 95% positive
Party-Based RPGChoices MatterStory RichCharacter CustomizationTurn-Based Tactics
- C
Changed
2018 · Adventure
16,107 reviews · 86% positive
CuteDifficultSexual ContentPsychological HorrorPuzzle
- I
- 9
911 Operator
2017 · Casual
14,419 reviews · 88% positive
SimulationStrategyManagementSingleplayerIndie
- L
- Y
- M
Monster Prom
2018 · Indie
12,280 reviews · 93% positive
Dating SimComedyLGBTQ+MultiplayerChoices Matter
- C
Caves of Qud
2024 · Adventure
12,006 reviews · 95% positive
Procedural GenerationTurn-Based CombatOpen WorldTurn-BasedTranshumanism
- L
Little Misfortune
2019 · Adventure
11,927 reviews · 92% positive
Psychological HorrorPoint & ClickIndieStory RichChoices Matter
- C
- T
- C
- S
Suzerain
2020 · Adventure
10,674 reviews · 92% positive
Visual NovelChoose Your Own AdventurePolitical SimInteractive FictionPolitical
- N
- K
Kindergarten
2017 · Adventure
10,318 reviews · 97% positive
FunnyGorePixel GraphicsSingleplayerViolent
- A
Ancestors: The Humankind Odyssey
2020 · Action
9,883 reviews · 79% positive
Open World Survival CraftSurvivalOpen WorldExplorationSingleplayer
- W
- P
Pathologic 2
2019 · Adventure
9,621 reviews · 92% positive
Story RichAtmosphericChoices MatterRPGDifficult
- D
- O
- M
Monster Train 2
2025 · Indie
8,771 reviews · 95% positive
StrategyCard GameRogue-likeTurn-Based StrategyTurn-Based Tactics
- B
- T
The Life and Suffering of Sir Brante
2021 · Adventure
8,200 reviews · 88% positive
Choices MatterStory RichRPGInteractive FictionChoose Your Own Adventure
- D
Death and Taxes
2020 · Adventure
7,902 reviews · 86% positive
Choices MatterStory RichSimulationPoint & ClickMultiple Endings
- K
Kingdom Rush Origins - Tower Defense
2018 · Indie
7,671 reviews · 96% positive
Tower DefenseStrategy2DSingleplayerDifficult
- T
- H
HighFleet
2021 · Action
7,079 reviews · 88% positive
SingleplayerIndieStrategyPost-apocalypticAction Roguelike
- T
THE LONGING
2020 · Adventure
7,012 reviews · 92% positive
Point & ClickWalking SimulatorChoose Your Own AdventureIdler2D
- B
- G
- D
- L
- T
The Cosmic Wheel Sisterhood
2023 · Adventure
5,688 reviews · 93% positive
Interactive FictionFemale ProtagonistMagicLGBTQ+Visual Novel
- T
- K
- O
- D
Dream Daddy: A Dad Dating Simulator
2017 · Casual
5,413 reviews · 92% positive
LGBTQ+Dating SimSexual ContentRomanceVisual Novel
- S
- G
Grocery Store Simulator
2024 · Action
5,355 reviews · 91% positive
Online Co-OpMultiplayerIndieFirst-PersonSimulation
- H
- H
- I
I Wani Hug that Gator!
2024 · Casual
5,206 reviews · 98% positive
Visual NovelStory RichRomanceChoose Your Own AdventureDating Sim
- S
Sol Cesto
2026 · Indie
4,974 reviews · 91% positive
Early AccessDungeon CrawlerTacticalRogue-likePuzzle
- I
- S
Scarlet Hollow
2021 · Adventure
4,938 reviews · 98% positive
Early AccessChoices MatterVisual NovelPsychological HorrorStory Rich
- B
- B
Beholder: Conductor
2025 · Adventure
4,757 reviews · 91% positive
Dystopian Choices MatterSingleplayerIndieStory Rich
- T
- R
- I
- E
Electrician Simulator
2022 · Adventure
4,121 reviews · 80% positive
SimulationEducationImmersive SimFirst-PersonIndie
- T
The Rise of the Golden Idol
2024 · Adventure
3,844 reviews · 92% positive
MysteryInvestigationDetectiveConspiracyAdventure
- G
Ghost Exile
2022 · Action
3,721 reviews · 89% positive
HorrorOnline Co-OpCo-opMultiplayerPsychological Horror
- T
The Cabin Factory
2024 · Adventure
3,503 reviews · 91% positive
HorrorPsychological HorrorWalking SimulatorChoices MatterImmersive Sim
- C
Class of '09: The Flip Side
2024 · Casual
3,375 reviews · 58% positive
ComedyVisual NovelDark ComedyChoose Your Own AdventureStory Rich
- S
SKALD: Against the Black Priory
2024 · Indie
3,360 reviews · 94% positive
StrategySingleplayerMinimalistAtmosphericExploration
- P
Paradise Killer
2020 · Adventure
3,314 reviews · 93% positive
Story RichInvestigationFemale ProtagonistOpen WorldExploration
- L
Love Curse: Find Your Soulmate
2025 · RPG
3,305 reviews · 95% positive
LGBTQ+Female ProtagonistVisual NovelDating SimChoices Matter
- D
Die in the Dungeon
2026 · Indie
3,302 reviews · 92% positive
Early AccessTurn-Based StrategyDungeon CrawlerChoices MatterRoguelike Deckbuilder
- O
Ostranauts
2026 · Indie
3,214 reviews · 77% positive
Early AccessTop-DownCyberpunkOpen WorldSimulation
- D
- O
- E
- N
- B
- R
- M
Monster Prom 3: Monster Roadtrip
2022 · Casual
2,828 reviews · 97% positive
Visual NovelLGBTQ+Dating SimComedyMultiplayer
- C
Coffee Talk Episode 2: Hibiscus & Butterfly
2023 · Adventure
2,519 reviews · 97% positive
ConversationRelaxingPixel GraphicsInteractive FictionVisual Novel
- A
Arco
2024 · Action
2,217 reviews · 96% positive
RPGTurn-Based StrategyAction-AdventureStory RichTurn-Based Combat
- D
- C
Cabernet
2025 · Adventure
2,082 reviews · 95% positive
SingleplayerFemale ProtagonistVampireChoices MatterSimulation
- T
- T
- M
- W
- H
- M
Monster Prom 4: Monster Con
2025 · Casual
1,910 reviews · 99% positive
Visual NovelComedyLGBTQ+Dating SimMultiplayer
- C
- V
Vagrus - The Riven Realms
2021 · Indie
1,781 reviews · 85% positive
Story RichOpen WorldDungeons & DragonsNarrativeStrategy RPG
- M
- O
- Y
Yes, Your Grace 2: Snowfall
2025 · Indie
1,515 reviews · 77% positive
Story RichChoices MatterSingleplayerIndieMedieval
- J
- G
- M
- T
Those Who Rule
2025 · Indie
1,139 reviews · 90% positive
Tactical RPGTurn-Based TacticsRPGStrategy RPGTurn-Based Strategy
- A
Anomaly Exit
2024 · Adventure
1,132 reviews · 90% positive
Online Co-OpHidden ObjectPuzzlePsychological HorrorHorror
- A
All Quiet in the Trenches
2024 · Indie
926 reviews · 90% positive
SurvivalWarStrategyWorld War IChoices Matter
- T
The Black Grimoire: Cursebreaker
2024 · Adventure
897 reviews · 83% positive
AdventureRPGCraftingOpen WorldSingleplayer
- S
- T
- D
- R
- B
- T
- D
Dustborn
2024 · Action
598 reviews · 66% positive
IndieStory RichSingleplayerComic BookChoices Matter
- L
Lawgivers II
2023 · Indie
581 reviews · 70% positive
Early AccessPolitical SimPoliticsSandboxCapitalism
- A
A Highland Song
2023 · Adventure
557 reviews · 87% positive
Exploration2D PlatformerNatureDynamic NarrationFemale Protagonist
- T
The Anomaly Project
2024 · Action
539 reviews · 81% positive
AdventureOnline Co-OpCasualPsychological HorrorWalking Simulator
- A
Arcadia Fallen
2021 · Adventure
510 reviews · 95% positive
Choose Your Own AdventureVisual NovelDating SimOtomeCharacter Customization
- O
- E
- H
Haunted House Renovator
2025 · Adventure
201 reviews · 46% positive
CasualSimulationDesign & IllustrationFirst-PersonAdventure
- M
Milling machine simulator
2022 · Action
188 reviews · 88% positive
SimulationSandboxRealisticEducationCrafting
- F
Front Office Football Nine
2023 · Indie
166 reviews · 80% positive
SportsSimulationFootball (American)StrategyChoices Matter
- B
- T
Frequently asked questions
- What are the best choices matter indie games?
- By Steam review count, indielist ranks 130 tracked choices matter indie games led by Undertale (312,017 reviews).
- How is the choices matter list built?
- This page uses SteamSpy user tags from tracked games, then ranks matching public games by Steam review count. It is not hand-picked.